Comments on: Gloating over the demise of progressive Jewry http://blog.maskil.info/2007/12/gloating-over-the-demise-of-progressive-jewry/ A secure, just Israel and a welcoming, pluralistic Judaism Mon, 06 Feb 2012 11:20:00 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Maskil http://blog.maskil.info/2007/12/gloating-over-the-demise-of-progressive-jewry/comment-page-1/#comment-50 Maskil Fri, 04 Jan 2008 10:26:00 +0000 http://blog.maskil.info/2007/12/gloating-over-the-demise-of-progressive-jewry/#comment-50 Thanks for the feedback Marc. I have taken note of your comments and have published your revised remarks as a form of revision. Your gentlemanly and scholarly approach (your comments on the JOI Blog) will do more to advance the Orthodox cause than the aggressive and hostile tone sometimes adopted in these discussions. Thanks for the feedback Marc. I have taken note of your comments and have published your revised remarks as a form of revision. Your gentlemanly and scholarly approach (your comments on the JOI Blog) will do more to advance the Orthodox cause than the aggressive and hostile tone sometimes adopted in these discussions.

]]> By: Maskil http://blog.maskil.info/2007/12/gloating-over-the-demise-of-progressive-jewry/comment-page-1/#comment-303 Maskil Fri, 04 Jan 2008 10:26:00 +0000 http://blog.maskil.info/2007/12/gloating-over-the-demise-of-progressive-jewry/#comment-303 Thanks for the feedback Marc. I have taken note of your comments and have published your revised remarks as a form of revision. Your gentlemanly and scholarly approach (your comments on the JOI Blog) will do more to advance the Orthodox cause than the aggressive and hostile tone sometimes adopted in these discussions. Thanks for the feedback Marc. I have taken note of your comments and have published your revised remarks as a form of revision. Your gentlemanly and scholarly approach (your comments on the JOI Blog) will do more to advance the Orthodox cause than the aggressive and hostile tone sometimes adopted in these discussions.

]]> By: MarcJ http://blog.maskil.info/2007/12/gloating-over-the-demise-of-progressive-jewry/comment-page-1/#comment-49 MarcJ Wed, 02 Jan 2008 21:36:00 +0000 http://blog.maskil.info/2007/12/gloating-over-the-demise-of-progressive-jewry/#comment-49 I believe that Dave, who wrote the entry to which you were responding, has indicated on that blog that he himself is not Orthodox. I am Orthodox (having become religious in the past few years) and asked him to apologize for some of his comments, after which he indicated that he was not an Orthodox Jew (of course that doesn't mean he shouldn't still apologize).<br/><br/>Although "Orthodox triumphalist" might not of necessity refer to an Orthodox Jew as author, it does seem to insinuate that an orthodox person wrote it. If you would amend your entry or post a correction to avoid confusion, it would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.<br/><br/>-marc I believe that Dave, who wrote the entry to which you were responding, has indicated on that blog that he himself is not Orthodox. I am Orthodox (having become religious in the past few years) and asked him to apologize for some of his comments, after which he indicated that he was not an Orthodox Jew (of course that doesn’t mean he shouldn’t still apologize).

Although “Orthodox triumphalist” might not of necessity refer to an Orthodox Jew as author, it does seem to insinuate that an orthodox person wrote it. If you would amend your entry or post a correction to avoid confusion, it would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

-marc

]]> By: MarcJ http://blog.maskil.info/2007/12/gloating-over-the-demise-of-progressive-jewry/comment-page-1/#comment-302 MarcJ Wed, 02 Jan 2008 21:36:00 +0000 http://blog.maskil.info/2007/12/gloating-over-the-demise-of-progressive-jewry/#comment-302 I believe that Dave, who wrote the entry to which you were responding, has indicated on that blog that he himself is not Orthodox. I am Orthodox (having become religious in the past few years) and asked him to apologize for some of his comments, after which he indicated that he was not an Orthodox Jew (of course that doesn't mean he shouldn't still apologize).Although "Orthodox triumphalist" might not of necessity refer to an Orthodox Jew as author, it does seem to insinuate that an orthodox person wrote it. If you would amend your entry or post a correction to avoid confusion, it would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.-marc I believe that Dave, who wrote the entry to which you were responding, has indicated on that blog that he himself is not Orthodox. I am Orthodox (having become religious in the past few years) and asked him to apologize for some of his comments, after which he indicated that he was not an Orthodox Jew (of course that doesn’t mean he shouldn’t still apologize).Although “Orthodox triumphalist” might not of necessity refer to an Orthodox Jew as author, it does seem to insinuate that an orthodox person wrote it. If you would amend your entry or post a correction to avoid confusion, it would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.-marc

]]>